top of page

SheMD Journal Club: But You Don't Look Like A Scientist

Here at sheMD, we believe in the importance of practicing Evidence-Based Medicine. We believe the same principles apply to discussing Gender and Medical Education. Therefore, we are bringing you an entire Journal Club series! Our series will focus on foundational and new literature within the gender and medicine space.

Today, we will be discussing the article entitled, But You Don’t Look Like A Scientist!: Women Scientists with Feminine Appearance are Deemed Less Likely to be Scientists.

Why is this article important?

  • Women are disproportionately underrepresented in STEM fields, in part due to gender bias in these fields.

  • There is a perceived incompatibility between femininity and science that negatively impacts women in STEM fields, which includes ideas and judgements made based solely on appearance.

Article Summary

What they looked at:

  • This study evaluated natural variations in physical appearance and whether they had an impact on the perceived likelihood that a female is a scientist.

How they measured things:

  • 80 female headshot photos of caucasian faculty (to avoid confounding) of top institutions in STEM fields were used as stimuli for participants to evaluate the likelihood that the person was a STEM scientist vs an early childhood educator. Participants were asked to rate the headshot from masculine to feminine, likable to unlikable, and unattractive to attractive.

  • A second study had participants estimate the likelihood of a male or female headshot being a journalist (gender neutral), scientist (masculine), or early childhood educator (feminine).

What were their outcomes:

  • Female scientists were rated as significantly more likely to be teachers. As the femininity rating increased, the rated likelihood of being a scientist decreased (p<0.001) and the likelihood of being a teacher increased (p<0.001).

  • The femininity rating of female headshots was negatively correlated to the rating of likelihood of being a scientist and positively correlated to the rating of likelihood of being a non-scientist (p<0.001).

Why do we care about this article?

What does this mean?

  • This research concluded that a feminine appearance affected career judgments for female scientists but had no effect on judgments of male scientists. They found increasing femininity decreased the perceived likelihood of that female being a scientist and increasing the perceived likelihood that the female was an early childhood educator. Past research has suggested that femininity and attractiveness are viewed as INCOMPATIBLE with science!

How does this apply to us?

  • So for #womeninstem, feminine appearance may erroneously signal that they are not well suited for science. Role incongruity theory tells us that if a person does not “fit” within a career because of a mismatch between that person’s gender role and the career role, then they may experience more prejudice. According to the article, "a woman who is more feminine in appearance than other women will elicit stronger perceived role incongruity and will therefore experience more prejudice than their less feminine counterparts."

Take Home Point

  • Should we try not to look feminine? NO! Be you. Look the way you want to look. As a wise friend always says, "YOU DO YOU GIRLFRIEND!" We just need to know that this gender bias exists. And that we will encounter it and have to defy it during our careers!

Similar Articles

  • For further reading on the topic, check out these articles!

  • Ashton-James CE, Tybur JM, Grießer V, Costa D. Stereotypes about surgeon warmth and competence: The role of surgeon gender. PLoS One. 2019 Feb 27;14(2):e0211890. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0211890. PMID: 30811457; PMCID: PMC6392236.

  • Bergsieker HB, Wilmot MO, Cyr EN, Grey CB. A threat in the network: STEM women in less powerful network positions avoid integrating stereotypically feminine peers. Group Process Intergroup Relat. 2021 Apr;24(3):321-349. doi: 10.1177/1368430219888274. Epub 2020 Jan 3. PMID: 33958955; PMCID: PMC8054113.

  • Dream S, Woolfolk M, Chen H. Gender role incongruency in general surgery applicants. Am J Surg. 2022 Sep;224(3):900-902. doi: 10.1016/j.amjsurg.2022.04.037. Epub 2022 May 7. PMID: 35562201.

72 views14 comments

14 Kommentare

The vaping industry has seen significant innovation and growth in recent years, elf bar 6000 with disposable vapes emerging as a particularly convenient option for both new and experienced users. These devices are designed to offer a hassle-free vaping experience, characterized by their pre-filled e-liquid and ready-to-use nature.

Gefällt mir

One of the key safety considerations with Generic Modalert is ensuring that it is taken at the correct dosage. Dosage recommendations can vary depending on the condition being treated and individual factors such as age and  buy modafinil overall health. It's essential to follow the dosage instructions provided by a healthcare professional carefully.

Gefällt mir

Nutzen Sie recycelte Materialien und Möbelstücke, um Kosten zu senken und gleichzeitig umweltfreundlich zu handeln. Baustoffe aus zweiter Hand, tinyhaus kaufen wie Holz, Fenster und Türen, können oft zu einem Bruchteil des Neupreises erworben werden. Auch Möbel und Einrichtungsgegenstände lassen sich günstig auf Flohmärkten oder Online-Plattformen finden und mit etwas Kreativität aufwerten.

Gefällt mir

Electrical junction box may appear unassuming, but they are integral components within electrical systems, wielding significant influence over safety, functionality, and efficiency. In this comprehensive guide, we'll unravel the importance of these boxes, exploring their roles, variations, installation methods, and expert strategies to optimize their performance.

Gefällt mir

¡Muchas gracias! Es un placer recibir tus buenos deseos en mi cumpleaños. Al celebrar otro año de vida, reflexiono sobre las experiencias vividas, los desafíos superados y los momentos de felicidad compartidos. Cada día es un regalo y una oportunidad para crecer, aprender y contribuir al mundo que nos rodea.Feliz cumpleaños Agradezco a todos aquellos que han sido parte de mi viaje, quienes han dejado una huella imborrable en mi corazón. Que este nuevo año esté lleno de alegría, amor y nuevas aventuras. Brindemos por la vida y por los sueños que están por cumplirse. ¡Salud!

Gefällt mir
bottom of page